mr-onion

Phase 39 Gate B Report — Fewer Visits (TFP-212, TFP-213, TFP-215)

Date: 2026-10-20 Tickets: TFP-212 (be94bff), TFP-213 (be94bff), TFP-215 (2be975c); the template baseline moved in f042d11. Evidence: benchmarks/2026-10-20-gate-b/. analysis.md has every number below. Targets: locked at Gate A (phase-39-run-concurrency-decision-record.md, “Gate A — targets locked”). Setup:

Bottom line

Run times (seconds; median, then each run)

Copy Suite A (before) B (TFP-212, 213) C (+ TFP-215) A to C Target
with-bugs Standard 1,342 (1,352, 1,342, 1,326) 919 (945, 910, 919) 854 (865, 854, 845) 36.4% 20%: met
with-bugs Security 205 (213, 205, 196) - 111 (110, 111, 113) 45.9% 30%: met
with-bugs Accessibility 206 (206, 201, 206) - 204 (203, 204, 206) 1.0% 30%: not met
clean Standard 1,025 (1,034, 1,025, 1,018) - 513 (510, 516, 513) 50.0% 20%: met
clean Security 197 (197, 197, 196) - 106 (106, 103, 106) 46.2% 30%: met
clean Accessibility 186 (188, 185, 186) - 170 (165, 171, 170) 8.6% 30%: not met

Why accessibility misses (measured, C, clean, run 1)

Check (per page, 20 pages) Shares the visit? Loads
The axe scan yes 20: it fails on 15 pages; the next shared check reloads after each failure
Checkboxes and radio buttons grouped yes 15 of 20 (after a failed scan it loads again)
Every form field has an accessible name no: it adds a probe element and removes and restores a placeholder 20
Tabbed through in reading order no: it presses Tab 20

Decision 7: the same results (analysis.md)

What else changed (for Emil)

For Emil: Gate B

The locked gate is not met: accessibility misses on both copies. Options:

  1. Keep TFP-212, 213 and 215, and move accessibility’s target to Gate C, where TFP-214 shares the two checks that change the page and put it back.
    • Standard and security are 36 to 50% faster with the same results.
    • Accessibility is no slower (1% and 9% faster), with the same results.
    • Recommended.
  2. As 1, and first run the axe scan last in each page’s group, so a failing scan costs no reload of the check after it. A small change to the pass’s ordering, measured against this session’s C.
    • Expected: about 15 fewer loads on clean (roughly 20 s, about 12%) and fewer on with-bugs.
    • Not enough for 30% alone.
  3. Apply the rule as locked: revert all three, and record this result. That gives up the Standard and security gains.