mr-onion

Post-Phase 42 Review — R3 Claims Audit Findings

Date: 2026-10-16 Scope: review step R3 (post-phase-42-review-plan.md). The Phase 38 to 42 records, the README, TEST_PLAN.md and the handover are read against the code at 6d8f7e4 and against R1’s numbers (TFP-207, benchmarks/2026-10-15-tfp207-regression/). Status: findings complete. Doc fixes D1 to D6 were approved by Emil and made from Cowork on 2026-10-16, uncommitted, for Code to commit. The Phase 39 amendment was locked the same day. The first pass (F1 to F4, S1 to S5, U1, U2) is carried over from post-phase-42-review-notes-2026-10-15.md, which stays as the working notes.

TFP-207 verified (Cowork, 2026-10-16)

R1’s numbers used below

  with-bugs Gate B with-bugs R1 clean Gate B clean R1
Tests 461 500 451 489
Failed 84 89 46 46
Run (wall) 1235 s 1535 s 1049 s 1131 s
Test time (sum of tests) 1127 s 1399 s n/a 1057 s
Median test 1.61 s 1.92 s n/a 1.63 s
Time in failing tests 410 s 493 s n/a 189 s
TFP-205 link tests — 39 tests, 104 s — 38 tests, 67 s

Score, Standard only: 30 found, 0 hinted, 7 missed. Gate B’s 33 needed Comprehensive security for 75, 80 and 82.

Findings

False

Stale

Understated, or a number missing its conditions

Holds (checked against R1)

Open questions for TFP-208 (from R1)

Doc fixes (approved by Emil 2026-10-16, made from Cowork)

# Fix File
D1 The three corrections above benchmarks/2026-10-15-tfp207-regression/outcome.md
D2 S1: Phase 41 complete 2026-10-13, Phase 42 complete 2026-10-15; Phase 39 entry pointing at the amendment product-roadmap.md
D3 F3, F5, F6, U3, U4 as correction notes dated 2026-10-16, without rewriting the history Phase 42 record
D4 S3, S6: a short fresh handover replacing the Phase 38 one (state, rules, next ticket) docs/HANDOVER_TO_CLAUDE_CODE_2026-10-16-review.md, old one deleted in the same commit
D5 F4, S2: header, overview, feature table (Phases 35 to 42), roadmap pointer; limitation 1 rewritten TEST_PLAN.md
D6 F1, F2, S4, S5, U1 (with both benchmark numbers), U2 README front door, last, after D1 to D5

All six are made. D4’s new handover is docs/HANDOVER_TO_CLAUDE_CODE_2026-10-16-review.md. The Phase 38 handover is still on disk, for Code to delete (git rm) in the same commit. Code commits these as docs commits; Cowork doesn’t commit.

Tickets